| Vault | Bars | Beam | Floor | All-Around |
| Botterman | Botterman | Botterman | Botterman | Botterman |
| Curtis | Curtis | Curtis | Curtis | Curtis |
| Lor | Moody | Lor | Lor | |
| Theuner-Rego | Theuner-Rego | (Theuner-Rego) | Theuner-Rego | (Theuner-Rego) |
| Pearce | Wilson | Sexton | Sexton | |
| Wilson | Bernard | Bernard | Kramer | |
| Moody | Knutson | Knutson | Zondervan | |
| Zondervan |
| Year | NCAA | Score | Big Ten | Score | Regional | Score | MVP | Coach |
|
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 |
n/a 8th n/a 7th 5th |
n/a 196.075 195.10 196.00 196.575 |
1st 1st 1st 4th 1st |
197.075 196.75 196.575 194.475 196.25 |
3rd 2nd 2nd 1st 1st |
195.70 196.375 196.05 196.00 196.60 |
Botterman Theuner-Rego Bruck, Deiley Theuner-Rego Ray |
Plocki Plocki Plocki Plocki Plocki |
| 2004 | 8th | 196.50 | 1st | 197.8 | 2nd | 196.375 | Ray | Plocki |
| 2003 | 5th | 196.05 | 1st | 197.45 | 1st | 196.825 | Deiley/Ryals | Plocki |
| 2002 | 7th | 196.175 | 1st | 196.475 | 2nd | 195.6 | Ray | Plocki |
| 2001 | 3rd | 197.175 | 1st | 197.15 | 1st | 197.225 | Ray | Plocki |
| 2000 | 6th | 195.725 | 1st | 197.85 | 1st | 196.55 | Cain | Plocki |
| 1999 | 2nd | 196.55 | 1st | 196.30 | 1st | 196.75 | Cain/Peters | Plocki |
| 1998 | 8th | 195.425 | 2nd | 194.90 | 2nd | 196.00 | Cain/Peters | Plocki |
| 1997 | 4th | 196.50 | 1st | 197.15 | 1st | 197.70 | Cain/Peters | Plocki |
| 1996 | 6th | 196.375 | 1st | 194.60 | 2nd | 196.275 | Marshall | Plocki |
| 1995 | 2nd | 196.425 | 1st | 196.50 | 2nd | 195.725 | Wymer | Plocki |
| 1994 | 4th | 195.15 | 1st | 194.85 | 3rd | 193.6 | Wymer | Plocki |
| 1993 | 9th | 193.125 | 1st | 192.925 | 4th | 193.00 | Wymer | Plocki |
| 1992 | n/a | n/a | 1st | 191.70 | 2nd | 189.775 | Wymer | Fry |