Michigan Wrestling Division III All-Americans
| Division III All-American | School | Year | Weight | Place | High School |
| Myers, James | Olivet | 2012 | 165 | 6th | Indian Creek, OH |
| Myers, James | Olivet | 2011 | 165 | 6th | Indian Creek, OH |
| Brew, Jason | Olivet | 2009 | 157 | 2nd | Sparta |
| Vanderhyde, Kyle | Olivet | 2008 | 174 | 4th | Sparta |
| Brew, Jason | Olivet | 2008 | 157 | 2nd | Sparta |
| Vanderhyde, Kyle | Olivet | 2007 | 174 | 2nd | Sparta |
| Torres, Justin | Olivet | 2003 | 197 | 6th | Holly |
| Cichoski, Dustin | Olivet | 2001 | 165 | 6th | n/a |
| Thomas, Eric | Olivet | 1994 | 275 | 2nd | n/a |
| Thomas, Eric | Olivet | 1993 | 275 | 5th | n/a |
| Engle, Ted | Olivet | 1991 | 118 | 6th | Delton Kellogg |
| Engle, Ted | Olivet | 1990 | 118 | 6th | Delton Kellogg |
| Pantaleo, Mike | Olivet | 1987 | 126 | 6th | n/a |
| Raut, John | Olivet | 1987 | 190 | 4th | n/a |
| Lake, Willie | Olivet | 1986 | 167 | 6th | n/a |
| Pantaleo, Mike | Olivet | 1985 | 126 | 3rd | n/a |
| Pantaleo, Dan | Olivet | 1985 | 142 | 2nd | Roseville |
| Pantaleo, Dan | Olivet | 1984 | 142 | 1st | Roseville |
| Labreque, Dave | Olivet | 1984 | 167 | 4th | n/a |
| Pantaleo, Dan | Olivet | 1983 | 142 | 5th | Roseville |
| Coon, Dan | Alma | 1983 | 177 | 5th | Fowlerville |
| Coon, Dan | Alma | 1982 | 177 | 5th | Fowlerville |
| Crooks, Steve | Kalamazoo | 1979 | 134 | 6th | Grandville |
| Crooks, Steve | Kalamazoo | 1978 | 134 | 6th | Grandville |
| Bates, Ron | Olivet | 1977 | 177 | 6th | n/a |
| Leyndyke, Jim | LSSU | 1974 | 126 | 4th | n/a |
| Jirikovic, Dave | LSSU | 1974 | 142 | 6th | Jackson Northwest |
| Fallis, Jim | LSSU | 1974 | 158 | 1st | Durand |