| Division I Team | Conference | State |
| Arizona State | Pacific 10 | Arizona |
| Cal Poly | Pacific 10 | California |
| Cal St.-Bakersfield | Pacific 10 | California |
| Cal St.-Fullerton | Pacific 10 | California |
| Cal-Davis | Pacific 10 | California |
| Northern Colorado | West Region | Colorado |
| U.S. Air Force | West Region | Colorado |
| Sacred Heart | Colonial | Connecticut |
| Deleware State | West Region | Deleware |
| Boise State | Pacific 10 | Idaho |
| Illinois | Big Ten | Illinois |
| Northwestern | Big Ten | Illinois |
| Northern Illinois | Mid-American | Illinois |
| Indiana | Big Ten | Indiana |
| Purdue | Big Ten | Indiana |
| Iowa | Big Ten | Iowa |
| Iowa State | Big Twelve | Iowa |
| Northern Iowa | West Region | Iowa |
| U.S. Navy | EIWA | Maryland |
| Maryland | Atlantic Coast | Maryland |
| Harvard | EIWA | Massachusetts |
| Boston University | Colonial | Massachusetts |
| Michigan | Big Ten | Michigan |
| Michigan State | Big Ten | Michigan |
| Eastern Michigan | Mid-American | Michigan |
| Central Michigan | Mid-American | Michigan |
| Minnesota | Big Ten | Minnesota |
| Missouri | Big Twelve | Missouri |
| Nebraska | Big Twelve | Nebraska |
| Princeton | EIWA | New Jersey |
| Rutgers | EIWA | New Jersey |
| Rider | Colonial | New Jersey |
| U.S. Army | EIWA | New York |
| Cornell | EIWA | New York |
| Binghamton St. | Colonial | New York |
| Hofstra | Colonial | New York |
| Appalachian State | Southern | North Carolina |
| North Carolina-Greensboro | Southern | North Carolina |
| Davidson | Southern | North Carolina |
| Gardner-Webb | West Region | North Carolina |
| Campbell | Colonial | North Carolina |
| Duke | Atlantic Coast | North Carolina |
| North Carolina | Atlantic Coast | North Carolina |
| North Carolina St. | Atlantic Coast | North Carolina |
| North Dakota St. | West Region | North Dakota |
| Ohio State | Big Ten | Ohio |
| Ohio University | Mid-American | Ohio |
| Kent State | Mid-American | Ohio |
| Cleveland State | Eastern Wrestling League | Ohio |
| Oklahoma | Big Twelve | Oklahoma |
| Oklahoma State | Big Twelve | Oklahoma |
| Oregon State | Pacific 10 | Oregon |
| Portland State | Pacific 10 | Oregon |
| Oregon | Pacific 10 | Oregon |
| Penn State | Big Ten | Pennsylvania |
| Duquesne | West Region | Pennsylvania |
| Millersville | West Region | Pennsylvania |
| Bloomsburgh | Eastern Wrestling League | Pennsylvania |
| Clarion | Eastern Wrestling League | Pennsylvania |
| Lock Haven | Eastern Wrestling League | Pennsylvania |
| Pittsburgh | Eastern Wrestling League | Pennsylvania |
| Lehigh | EIWA | Pennsylvania |
| Franklin&Marshall | EIWA | Pennsylvania |
| Pennsylvania | EIWA | Pennsylvania |
| East Stroudsburg | EIWA | Pennsylvania |
| Bucknell | EIWA | Pennsylvania |
| Drexel | Colonial | Pennsylvania |
| Brown | EIWA | Rhode Island |
| The Citadel | Southern | South Carolina |
| Tennessee-Chattanooga | Southern | Tennessee |
| Utah Valley St. | West Region | Utah |
| VMI | Southern | Virginia |
| Liberty | West Region | Virginia |
| George Mason | Colonial | Virginia |
| Old Dominion | Colonial | Virginia |
| Virginia | Atlantic Coast | Virginia |
| Virginia Tech | Atlantic Coast | Virginia |
| West Virginia | Eastern Wrestling League | West Virginia |
| Wisconsin | Big Ten | Wisconsin |